On Sacred Ground: Melinda Pupillo on Accompanying Young Adults

Headshot of Melinda Pupillo.

For LSTC alumna Melinda Pupillo, campus ministry creates room for students to ask difficult questions, encounter one another across differences, and discover that God’s grace accompanies them through uncertainty.

Sometimes a conversation about religious disagreement becomes a conversation about something far more personal.

During her five and a half years as chaplain at Augustana College in Rock Island, Illinois, Melinda Pupillo occasionally met with Christian students who questioned her leadership and her expansive understanding of the Gospel. One such student arrived seemingly seeking counsel, then began challenging how she could affirm particular beliefs or practices while remaining faithful to the Bible.

Pupillo wanted to understand the person behind the challenge.

“More, I was concerned about young person’s heart, longing to better understand their deep questions and their hunger for religious integrity,” she recalls.

She shared her faith story, then invited the student to share theirs. As they talked, a difficult relationship between the student and their father emerged. Pupillo asked a gentle question and listened.

“Tears began to flow and suddenly we were on sacred ground.”

For Pupillo, the encounter illustrates what chaplaincy makes possible: a relationship in which someone can bring strong convictions and still find room to be vulnerable.

“Chaplaincy allows space for each person to name the sacred stories that hold them, and to also walk alongside a person helping them to grow.”

A Call to the Inbetweens

Pupillo’s interest in campus ministry developed during two years serving as pastor at Holden Village. The young adult staff impressed her with their inclusive practices and commitment to compassionate justice. Visiting college groups also brought opportunities to connect with chaplains and professors, who encouraged her to consider working with students.

“I love journeying the inbetweens of life with people and young adults know all about liminal spaces,” she says.

That encouragement helped her recognize a call to accompany people navigating questions of identity, faith, and purpose.

At Augustana, the work was broad and demanding. After five and a half years, Pupillo stepped away for sabbatical rest. Looking back, she identifies individual conversations with students as the most meaningful part of her ministry.

Many students worried about whether they were making the choices God expected of them. They asked, “Am I doing what God wants?” and “How do I know what is the best choice to make in this situation?”

Pupillo helped them consider a relationship with God that allowed room for their own judgment, desires, and growth.

“Too often we limit God’s power and perspective in our lives, and then live in fear of doing life wrong,” she says.

Her response began with grace. From that foundation, she encouraged students to recognize God’s image within themselves and develop trust in their inner wisdom.

Making Room for Encounter

Building relationships across religious differences sometimes began with something as simple as showing up. By attending students’ cultural and multifaith events, Pupillo demonstrated an interest in their lives that could open the door to later conversations.

Other opportunities required a little invention.

Following a recommendation from a Muslim professor in the religion department, the campus offered an afternoon of “speed-faithing.” Held in the student center coffee shop, the event invited students and faculty into brief, paired conversations about religious experience.

A Jain professor and a Jewish sophomore discussed prayer. A pagan junior and a Catholic senior talked about their favorite religious celebrations. When the allotted conversations ended, participants wanted to keep talking.

The experience reflected a conviction Pupillo traces to her theological education at LSTC. Beginning with her Unity and Diversity class, she encountered a community where different perspectives and expressions of faith were treated as sacred.

“Our breadth of human experience was not only welcomed, but ultimately theologically grounded in our various courses of study.”

Hope in the Conversation

Pupillo sees a desire among students, religious and nonreligious alike, to build relationships across differences. She also recognizes how fear of rejection can make honest conversation difficult.

She believes chaplains can help students enter those conversations with greater confidence. Lutheran theology’s embrace of paradox offers a way to remain present when ideas appear incompatible, allowing disagreement to become an opportunity for deeper understanding.

“Students have a God-given hunger for this kind of human exchange already, and that gives me hope for our future as peoples of faith.”

Back to top